Managerial
women working in organizations with values more supportive of work-personal
life balance have reported greater job and career satisfaction, less work
stress, less intention to quit, greater family satisfaction, fewer
psychosomatic symptoms and more positive emotional well-being (Burke, 2001) Additionally,
corporate culture and environment strongly favors men over women where men are
likely to be promoted to middle and senior management at a faster pace than
women (Tlaiss & Kauser, 2011). It is clear that gender realities may
prevent corporations from taking full advantage of the true potential of their
women employees by stifling their growth and denying their opportunities to
show their worth.
To
retain employees, employers need to believe that the best possible investment
is in their employees. While many senior
managers believe loyalty is dead, research shows people still make a commitment when they feel valued
and included. Managers underestimate how much people want to know and how much
they care for the organization (Padron, 2004). To keep employees motivated,
employers must create a positive work environment and give employees
opportunities to grow. When employees are motivated, there is retention or
reduction in turnover, and enthusiastic employees will out produce and
outperform the unmotivated employees (Honore, 2009).
2.6.4 Women & Children
The
strains of balancing work and domestic life definitely affected career
progression of the women managers. Children had made the greatest impact on the
careers of working mothers. It seems exhausting to balance the demands of
full-time work and childcare. Single women are expected to bear the brunt of
dependent care in their families by caring responsibilities of elderly
relatives. Gordon and Whelan-Berry (2005) said that women in a later life stage
will no longer be concerned with childcare and their focus on career may also
change. By the time a woman reaches her thirties, she is often beginning to
establish herself in her career, and at the same time is reaching the older
years in terms of child-bearing. In organizations where long hours at the work
place are considered important for career advancement, new mothers are often
faced with identity dilemmas and difficult career decisions. The women
established in their career and the older women at a senior level were
concerned with choices related to how they were supposed to work and how
restrictive this way in terms of flexible working life. Women with children
were greatly affected by long hours as they had to juggle between childcare and
the nature of the job working hours. Many childcare centers operate according
to office hours and need fixed attendance. Tharenou (2005) stated that lack of
adequate childcare has been reported by women managers as a barrier and
ultimately damaging to their career. This has been supported by Liff and Ward
(2001) statement that women cannot be mothers and career women concurrently.
Due to that matter, women managers may choose to remain single and childless in
order to minimize their role conflicts. Despite of that, Tharenou (2005) have a
different view on this matter as he stated that having children does not
decrease women manager’s career progress.
2.6.5
Job Stress
In
a recent review, Perry-Jenkins et al (2000) reported that job stress and
conflict are related to various aspects of distress, and these in turn are
related to poorer marital relations, parent-child relations, and child
outcomes. In large part, because of the demands of being a ‘‘24/7’’ industry,
hotel companies often have norms that encourage employees, especially managers,
to work as many hours as possible, including weekends and holidays.
Indeed,
managers in Stalcup and Pearson’s (2001) study mentioned long hours and not
having enough time to spend with families as a major reason for turnover.
Nonstandard, irregular hours have also been well-established as a correlate of
lower marital quality and divorce, less time with family, children with more
problem behaviors, and increased conflict (Presser 2000, 2004). Not only are employees
often required to keep long and irregular hours, but there is an expectation
that employees, especially managers, will be physically present as much as
possible, regardless of the actual necessity of being there. Munck called this
the ‘‘culture of face time’’ (2001:125)
According
to Hamid Sheeba 2011 It said, “Today’s fast paced lifestyle calls for managing
high levels of competition, stress, tension and work/life balance. The high
price to pay for this lifestyle wreaks havoc on human minds and results in
stressed-out individuals. People are not able to manage all the demands on them
and buckle under pressure. Stress brings failure and failure brings more stress
which becomes a vicious cycle, eventually resulting in falling performance. “As
further pointed out by the author, the individual member goes through
humiliation as he is not able to match the performance level of others and
since performance alone is the key for any hike in salary or winning an award,
under performance at work leads to low level of morale and job satisfaction.
2.6.6 Time Constrains of Job in hotels
In large part because of the demands of
being a ‘‘24/7’’ industry, hotel companies often have norms that encourage
employees, especially managers, to work
as many hours as possible, including weekends and holidays. Indeed, managers in
Stalcup and Pearson’s (2001) study mentioned long hours and not having enough
time to spend with families as a major reason for turnover. Not only are
employees often required to keep long and irregular hours, but there is an
expectation that employees, especially managers, will be physically present as
much as possible, regardless of the actual
necessity of being there. Munck called this the ‘‘culture of face time’’
(2001:125).
2.6.7 Glass Ceiling Phenomena
Glass
ceiling is a transparent barrier that applies to women as a group who kept from
advancing to higher positions simply because they are female. Weyer (2007)
declared although women’s visibility in the lower level of management is
increasing, there is still continuance relevance in the pattern of gender
inequality in leadership position. Gender discrimination continues to keep
women stagnating at lower management levels within their organizations
(Metcalfe, 2006, 2007, 2008; Moghadam, 2004). Women are either totally scarce
or poorly represented at the top level administration in core areas. More
studies have found out that women normally perform the most undesirable, lowest
status in hospitality, involve less skills and less-obvious career paths
(Purcell, 1996; Woods and Viehland, 2000; Korczynski,2002; Adib and Guerrier,
2003). In Asia, the concept of “glass ceiling” is somewhat differ than in the
West countries. Studies that have been conducted using Asian found that lack of
females in managerial positions (not necessarily top management positions) as
an indicator of the glass ceiling effect. Olson & Walker (2004) shown that
women executives distinguished themselves with other group of women in
business. Hence, this has enacting a comparable pattern to men who assert power
and status through differentiation from other men and women. For those
executives’ women studied, there was some sort of a fine line between not being
one of the “boys” and not being associated with typical femininity.
2.6.8 Old Boys network
Gransmark
(2010) described old boys’ network situation with the dominant group is
over-represented among the recruiters for high-status jobs and prefer to hire
employees with a similar background as themselves as well as act as gatekeepers,
reducing the possibilities for others to obtain the high-status jobs. The old
boys’ network can be defined as a system of social networking and perceptions
alleged to exist prevalently among certain communities and social strata.
Taylor (2001) defined members of this old-boys network by an attempt to shield
them from performing with opportunistic or incompetent individuals by dealing
uncommonly with unproven nonmembers only. In male dominated fields, there
exists doubt if women can ever accomplish a job as well as men. Employers also
doubt if women can work successfully with men as their colleagues. Homo-social
practices such as marginalization and competitiveness are demonstrated in
establishment where male managers portray a fondness for “men and men’s company’
(Broadbridge & Hearn, 2008). According to El-Ghannam (2002) and Eagly &
Carli (2007), gender role attitudes are related with the characteristics to
individuals in childhood norms where females and males acquire different
gender-related attitudes and behaviors. Therefore, women have been culturally
socialized adopting certain behaviors and traits that lead them fulfilling
assumed roles such as dealing with domestic responsibilities, leaving the
managerial positions to be filled by men (Cleveland, Stockdale & Murphy,
2000).
2.6.9 Lack of Mentorship
There is the lack
of or minimal mentorship opportunities, which raises difficulties for women
to get access to promotions, higher income, and ultimately increase in their
career satisfaction (Blake-Beard, 2001). The lack of mentoring programs
reflects less opportunity for women to look up to someone they would consider a
role model and who can guide them on their way to higher managerial functions.
Certainly, those women who are hoping to receive some form of recognition about
their performance – elements regarded as essential for advancement and usually
supported by mentors – do not necessarily get it. One bigger obstacle women
face is the trouble finding female mentors. Indeed, as many women are excluded
from some networks because of their gender, they would benefit more from the
advice of women who have faced similar hurdles in their careers (Elmuti, et
al., 2003) rather than feeling uncomfortable in a cross-gender mentoring
relationship (Linehan & Scullion, 2008).
No comments:
Post a Comment